Convergence of Riemann Sums
In a previous question we used rectangles on a 10x10
grid to
approximate the integral

where D is the ellipse with axes 6/5 and 1.
This is equivalent to the double iterated integral

According to the theory of Riemann sums (discussed in class) this
integral should equal the limit of the area of our approximation
as the grid gets finer and finer.
Question #5
- Use the
leftbox2d
command to approximate the area of
the ellipse for several grid sizes. For example you might want to use:
-
grid=[10,10]
- grid=[12,12]
- grid=[15,15]
- grid=[20,20]
- grid=[25,25]
- Plot the approximate area versus the total number
of boxes in your grid.
- Indicate the true value of the area of the ellipse on your graph.
Would you say that the approximate areas are converging quickly
or slowly to the actual area? Do the approximations
increase monotonically
towards the actual area? Explain
why you think the graph looks like it does.
- Based on your graph, try to estimate how many rectangles
we'd need in a square grid in order to
- approximate the area to within 0.05 of the true area AND
- ensure that if we refine the grid
(that is, increase the number of rectangles)
then the new approximate area will remain
within 0.05 of the true area.
How confident are you in your answer? (You may want to compute
approximations for more grid sizes.)
Up: Introduction
Previous: Approximating Volume
Frederick J. Wicklin<fjw@geom.umn.edu>
Document Created: Fri Jan 27 1995
Last modified: Tue Feb 6 10:57:21 1996