A Proof of the Duality of Conics

Theorem: A Line Conic is a Point Conic

We pick two lines and call them the axes, letting the point (a,0) on the first correspond with the point (0,(pa+q/ra+s)) on the second. Since we have not yet specified any basis points on these axes, we will do so in such a way that (infinity,0) corresponds to (0,0) and (0,0) corresponds to (0,infinity). Then the fractional linear transform a -> (pa+q)/(ra+s) will reduce to the form a -> k/a.

We want to find points on these lines such that their locus is a curve tangent to all of the lines. On any line l(a), the point we want is lim (l(a).l(a+r)) as r->0.

So, say we have two lines:

x    y           x      y
- + --- = 1 and --- + ------- = 1
a   k/a         a+r   k/(a+r)

After a crossmultiplication:

kx + (a+r)(a+r)y = ka + kr
kx + (a  )(a  )y = ka

After a subtraction: (2ar+rr)y = kr

Dividing by r: (2a+r)y = k

Thus y = k/(2a+r);
     x = a - aay/k = a - aa/(2a+r).
We take the limits of these quantities as r approaches 0, and find that (x,y)=(a/2,k/2a). So xy-k/4=0. This equation states that a particular quadratic function of x and y is zero; therefore it represents a point conic.

Theorem: A Point Conic is a Line Conic

We now choose our axes in the affine plane so that our conic has the equation xx+yy=1. Then xdx + ydy = 0; dy/dx = -x/y. We now use the parameterization x=cos(t), y=sin(t); then our tangent line will be

y - sin(t)   dy   -cos(t)
---------- = -- = ------- = -cot(t)
x - cos(t)   dx    sin(t)
This intersects the tangent line x=-1 at y=(cos(t)+1)/sin(t)
This intersects the tangent line y=-1 at x=(sin(t)+1)/cos(t)

Then x=(y+1)/(y-1), and the sets of points on the ranges are related by a fractional linear transformation. So they are also related by a projectivity, and indeed the line conic is a point conic.